Criticism
Despite his public achievements, Raymond has attracted a certain amount of criticism. Many critics accuse him of hijacking the free software movement for the sake of self promotion. His forthright rejection of the moral and ethical arguments of RMS and the Free Software Foundation in favor of more a pragmatic, market-friendly stance, has exacerbated some pre-existing political tensions in the community. There has also been some acrimony between Raymond and Linux developers, after the Linux project's refusal to incorporate CML2, an alternative kernel configuration system developed by Raymond himself.
It has been argued that Raymond has never actually written any significant
software, unlike Linus Torvalds, Richard Stallman or Alan Cox. His critics claim that most of the software that he lists on his webpage are originally
authored and copyrighted by other people and ESR usually contributes with bug fixes or a few minor features. They eventually get listed as software that he has "co authored".
The software authored by him are usually trivial and often just simple scripts, conversion utilities and the like. ESR is known to maintain "co-authorship" of lots of such projects which he "maintains". Though he has contributed very little free software himself, he mainatins a dozen FAQs, the jargon file and writes lots of essays.
Raymond is an avowed libertarian. He is known to have a strong interest
in science fiction, is an enthusiastic amateur musician,
and has a black belt in taekwondo. His public advocacy of Second Amendment rights and belligerent support for the 2003 Iraq War has nettled some hackers, but he seems to enjoy the
controversy this engenders.
External links
Parodies
- Trollse.cx - A Goatse.cx parody which features Eric S. Raymond instead of the actual infamous hello.jpg picture on the front page.
Quote
- Anybody who has ever owned a dog who barked when strangers came near its owner's property has experienced the essential continuity between animal territoriality and human property. Our domesticated cousins of the wolf are instinctively smarter about this than a good many human political theorists.
- - from Homesteading the Noosphere.